S1E44 - The Billboard on Route 19, October 1997

In October 1997, a man named Carl Pendelton drove past a billboard on Route 19 in Jessup County every day. It advertised a motel that had been demolished in 1983. But the sign never came down—the county just stopped paying for it. Carl started noticing small changes: the lettering looked newer somehow, the phone number at the bottom had a working area code. One night, on a dare from his brother, he called the number. A woman answered. She said her name was Margie, and she'd been expecting him. What Carl found at the address the billboard directed him to was no...