S11E18 - Oli Herbert
Published: June 12, 2026
Duration: 50:50
"Apparently he left the house after I went to bed so I couldn't stop him and bring him back inside."
On the afternoon of 16 October 2018, Elizabeth Herbert called the Connecticut State Police and reported her husband, 44-year-old Oli, missing. Officers responded to the property on Hydeville Pond in Stafford Springs, where they searched the grounds. Eventually, they found the body of Elizabeth's husband at the edge of the pond, laying face down in just a few inches of water.
In the weeks and months to come, a bizarre story would begin to play out in the...
On the afternoon of 16 October 2018, Elizabeth Herbert called the Connecticut State Police and reported her husband, 44-year-old Oli, missing. Officers responded to the property on Hydeville Pond in Stafford Springs, where they searched the grounds. Eventually, they found the body of Elizabeth's husband at the edge of the pond, laying face down in just a few inches of water.
In the weeks and months to come, a bizarre story would begin to play out in the...