Science of Justice

S1E30 - Are You Testing Your Case Too Late?

Published: December 10, 2025

Duration: 30:32

We challenge the habit of late-stage theme building and show why persuasion in civil trials starts six to twelve months out. Using cognitive science, psychometrics, and language framing, we map a path to a single, coherent story that jurors accept with confidence.

• why jurors construct stories rather than tally facts
• the risk of inferred events and causal gaps
• the four pillars of story acceptance coverage, coherence, completeness, uniqueness
• mapping narrative features to legal elements
• early theme testing as leverage and risk mitigation
• iterative focus groups, simulations, and psychometric modeling
• identifying and neutralising v...