What Was Sitting Behind Caleb Flynn's Garage Door That Night

Caleb Flynn told 911 that an intruder broke into his Tipp City, Ohio, home through the garage and shot his wife Ashley twice in the head. He told officers he was in the next room with their daughters. He told them his 9mm handgun was stolen from his truck in the garage. Prosecutors allege none of it happened the way Caleb described. They allege he shot Ashley himself and staged the entire house to look like a break-in.

The evidence that allegedly shattered his story starts in the garage. Officers found the side door open -- the door...