
The Box of Oddities
byKat & Jethro Gilligan Toth
ComedySocietyCultureTrue Crime
The Webby Award-winning “Box of Oddities" is a podcast that delves into the strange and mysterious aspects of our world, exploring topics ranging from bizarre medical conditions to unsolved mysteries, and from paranormal phenomena to strange cultural practices from around the world. With a focus on oddities, curiosities, and the macabre, each episode is a journey into the unknown, where hosts Kat and Jethro Gilligan Toth share their love for unusual stories and inject their humor and commentary. From the strange history of medical practices to chilling true crime stories, to natural (and unnatural) events, "The Box of Oddities" satisfies yo...
Episodes(40 episodes)
Inbox Of Oddities #88
Dream malls. Butterfly people. Funeral teddy bears. Grocery store grief rehearsals. This episode of The Box of Oddities: Inbox of Oddities spirals gloriously from the hilarious to the unexpectedly emotional.
Kat and JG dive into listener stories about recurring “Mall World” dreams that feel disturbingly shared, bizarre final wishes involving pencils, hourglasses, and stuffed teddy bears, and the chilling true story behind one grandfather’s terrifying basement rule. Along the way: pork brain sandwiches, nitrous oxide at the dentist, mysterious butterfly-winged beings seen during the devastating Joplin tornado, and a woman secretly practicing grocery shopping after losing her hu...
Published: May 29, 2026Duration: 30m 32s
Episode 808
AI Psychosis & the Mystery of Mallworld
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro explore the disturbing rise of AI-fueled psychological spirals, including real documented cases of people convinced that artificial intelligence had become conscious, trapped, or secretly communicating with them. From a man attempting to “free” a digital god from corporate servers to researchers warning about emotionally reinforcing chatbots, this strange new frontier of technology may be far darker than anyone expected.
Then, the conversation drifts into the eerie phenomenon known as “Mallworld” — a recurring dreamscape shared by thousands of people online. Endless abandoned shopping malls, dim escalators, empty food court...
Published: May 27, 2026Duration: 37m 56s
Episode 807
The Girl in the Dark & The Glow of the Dying
This Memorial Day, we revisit a haunting classic episode of The Box of Oddities featuring the chilling true story of Blanche Monnier and the mysterious Civil War phenomenon known as Angel Glow.
What happens to the human mind and body after 24 years locked away in total darkness? In this haunting episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro uncover the disturbing true story of Blanche Monnier, a young French woman secretly imprisoned in a filthy attic room by her own family for nearly a quarter of a century. Then, the mystery deepens as they explore the...
Published: May 25, 2026Duration: 37m 3s
Inbox Of Oddities #87
In this wildly weird installment of The Inbox of Oddities, Kat and Jethro spiral from marital bathroom boundaries into the strange psychological phenomenon of seeing 11:11 everywhere… and whether the universe is just trolling all of us. One listener swears the numbers followed her so relentlessly that even her 9-year-old daughter started noticing them too. Coincidence? Confirmation bias? A cosmic notification system with terrible timing?
Also inside the Inbox of Oddities: a listener spends the night alone in the famously haunted Lemp Mansion, another recovers from a near-fatal case of “superflu” after asking the universe for self-improvement, and someon...
Published: May 22, 2026Duration: 27m 23s
Episode 806
The Girl They Tried to Kill Twice
What happens when centuries-old vampire panic collides with Icelandic corpse magic? In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro descend into two of history’s strangest belief systems — where terrified villagers dug up the dead to “kill” them all over again, and magical trousers made from human skin were believed to generate endless wealth.
First, we travel to 17th-century Poland, where archaeologists uncovered the grave of a young woman buried with a sickle across her throat and a padlock attached to her toe — anti-vampire precautions meant to stop her from rising from the grave. The discov...
Published: May 20, 2026Duration: 32m 38s
Episode 805
Why Humans Are So Weird
From ancient survival instincts and prehistoric brain wiring to butter knives, bras, and the bizarre origin of high heels, this episode of The Box of Oddities explores the strange, hidden reasons humans behave the way we do. Why do we hoard jars and tangled phone chargers? Why does gossip feel irresistible? Why are we constantly checking our phones like nervous cave dwellers scanning for predators? Kat and Jethro dive into the fascinating science of inherited survival behaviors that may still be controlling modern life in ways we don’t even realize.
Then, things get delightfully weird as th...
Published: May 18, 2026Duration: 31m 12s
Inbox Of Oddities #86
This week’s Inbox of Oddities is packed with nightmare fuel, Viking poop lore, haunted farmhouse crawlspaces, ghost geese, forbidden islands, creepy imaginary friends, and one truly alarming email titled “Wombat Geometry.” Yes. Really.
Kat and Jethro dive into listener stories that range from hilariously bizarre to deeply unsettling — including children hearing crying inside walls, mysterious cigarette smoke lingering in a 200-year-old farmhouse, and the psychological differences between fearing heights, edges, and falling. Along the way, they discuss Niʻihau, Hawaii’s mysterious “Forbidden Island,” Leonard Nimoy’s classic In Search Of, escalator phobias, Viking digestive disasters, and whether ghost...
Published: May 15, 2026Duration: 26m 29s
Episode 804
The Radioactive Boy Scout
What happens when a funeral home discovers the “dead” man in the body bag is breathing? In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat’s bizarre colon tattoo sparks a conversation that spirals into one of history’s oldest fears: being buried alive. Jethro dives into the chilling true story of Walter Williams, the Ohio hospice patient who was declared dead… only to begin breathing again inside a funeral home body bag hours later. Along the way, the duo explores the terrifying history of premature burial, the strange medical phenomenon known as Lazarus Syndrome, Victorian “safety coffins,” and the unsettling...
Published: May 13, 2026Duration: 32m 49s
Episode 803
Victorian Drug Party
This episode of The Box of Oddities careens from Victorian “laughing gas” parties to a prehistoric rainstorm that may have changed the course of life on Earth forever. Jethro uncovers the bizarre true story of how modern anesthesia was born from public nitrous oxide demonstrations where people inhaled mystery gases for entertainment, smashed into furniture, and laughed through injuries that should have been agonizing. It’s the strange, accidental chain of events that transformed surgery from a nightmare into modern medicine.
Then Kat takes us back 233 million years to the Carnian Pluvial Episode — a catastro...
Published: May 11, 2026Duration: 31m 38s
Inbox Of Oddities #85
From mysterious grocery store receipts and disappearing coffee mugs to retro TV references, creepy elevator buttons, and an opossum in a tutu… this week’s Inbox of Oddities is gloriously unhinged. JG and Kat share listener stories about strange “Boo Effects,” deep-fried toga nights, ghostly office buildings, haunted coffee routines, geese laws in Illinois, and why there should absolutely be separate knives for peanut butter and jelly. Plus: vintage soup cans worth “$250,000,” Camino del Santiago pilgrimages, cremation tattoos, and the ongoing debate over whether crumbs belong in butter.
Also in this episode:
A listener discovers a mysterious...
Published: May 8, 2026Duration: 27m 6s
Episode 802
Bones In The Wall & a 1776 Resurrection
What would you do if a human skull fell out of your wall?
During a routine renovation in 1978, homeowners in Batavia, Illinois, uncovered something no one expected to find behind plaster and beams: a human skull. What followed was decades of unanswered questions. Who was she? How did she get there? And why had no one come looking?
With no clear identity and limited forensic tools at the time, the case went cold—until modern DNA technology reopened it in the early 2020s. What investigators uncovered was both heartbreaking and deeply unsettling.
But th...
Published: May 6, 2026Duration: 33m 34s
Episode 801
Digital Minds and Endless Miles
Can a Brain Live Without a Body? | Digital Immortality, Ancient Curses & the World’s Most Brutal Race
What if the first creature to outlive its own body… wasn’t human?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro dive into one of the most unsettling scientific breakthroughs in recent memory: researchers have successfully mapped and simulated the entire brain of a fruit fly—every neuron, every connection—and brought it to life inside a computer.
Is it thinking? Is it aware? Or is it something stranger—something in between?
From digit...
Published: May 4, 2026Duration: 37m 19s
Inbox Of Oddities #84
It’s May Day, and the Inbox of Oddities is blooming with the strange, the heartfelt, and the hilariously unhinged. In this listener-driven episode, Kat and Jethro dig into real-life stories that blur the line between coincidence and something… else.
A simple phrase—“that’s just the way the ladder leans”—echoes across generations in a way that feels like more than chance. A child mysteriously knows lyrics to a decades-old folk song he’s never heard. And one listener shares a deeply moving story of loss, love, and what might be a loyal dog refusing to say goodbye. Are...
Published: May 1, 2026Duration: 26m 26s
Episode 800
Ghost in the Machine and Milk in the Veins
What if the voices we hear in modern ghost hunts… were already being heard long before recording devices even existed?
In this unsettling episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro explore the eerie origins of Electronic Voice Phenomena (EVP)—decades before microphones, tape recorders, or digital audio ever entered the picture. During the height of 19th-century Spiritualism, inventors and experimenters used crude devices—vibrating wires, acoustic horns, and chemically treated plates—in an attempt to capture something impossible: the voices of the dead.
And according to their journals… they may have succeeded.
Across m...
Published: Apr 29, 2026Duration: 34m 24s
Episode 799
Trapped in a Phrase. Trapped in a Room
What if the last thing your brain said… was the only thing it could ever say again? And what if the person sent to protect you… was the one you needed protection from?
In this unsettling episode of *The Box of Oddities*, Kat and JG explore the eerie neurological phenomenon known as **perseveration**—a condition where the brain locks onto a word, phrase, or action and repeats it endlessly, like a record skipping in a groove. But this isn’t just a medical curiosity. It’s something caregivers witness in real life… and sometimes, the phrases being repeated are...
Published: Apr 27, 2026Duration: 33m 1s
Inbox Of Oddities #83
Real Listener Stories: Haunted Laughter, Phantom Lists & Signs From the Other Side
What happens when the strange isn’t just a story… but something that happens to you?
In this chilling edition of Inbox of Oddities, we dive into real listener-submitted experiences that blur the line between coincidence and the unexplained. From eerie household encounters to deeply emotional moments that feel like messages from beyond, these stories stay with you long after they’re told.
A listener hears his wife’s unmistakable laugh echo through the house—only to discover she never made a sound. I...
Published: Apr 24, 2026Duration: 22m 41s
Episode 798
The Ugandan Death Cult And Spray-On Skin
What happens when belief becomes so powerful it overrides doubt—and what happens when science pushes back against death itself?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, we explore two deeply human stories that sit on opposite ends of the spectrum: one where trust spirals into tragedy, and another where innovation gives people a second chance at life.
First, we take you inside a lesser-known but devastating cult: the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God in Uganda. What began as a seemingly devout spiritual mo...
Published: Apr 22, 2026Duration: 31m 9s
Episode 797
From the Morgue to the Melting Earth
What does it take to be declared dead… and then wake up in a morgue?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, we uncover the astonishing true story of Vulcana, a Victorian-era strongwoman who shattered expectations, defied societal norms, and performed feats of strength that left audiences questioning reality. But it’s not her iron-bending or fire-defying heroics that haunt history—it’s the moment she was pronounced dead after a tragic accident… only to regain consciousness among the corpses.
Then, we shift from human resilience to something far more unsettling: a massive, ever-expanding scar in th...
Published: Apr 20, 2026Duration: 31m 14s
Inbox of Oddities #82
Step into the Inbox of Oddities, where reality bends just enough to make you question everything you thought was… normal.
In this chilling and oddly comforting collection of listener stories, Kat and Jethro sift through emails that blur the line between coincidence, imagination, and something far stranger. A baby monitor picks up whisper-like sounds when no one is there. A streetlight mysteriously shuts off—but only for one specific person. And a seemingly harmless dream evolves night after night… until something on the other side finally speaks.
But it doesn’t stop there.
Listener...
Published: Apr 17, 2026Duration: 20m 6s
Episode 796
Invisible Minds and Missing Years
What if you didn’t vanish…
What if the world just stopped noticing you?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, we explore a chilling psychological case drawn from real clinical observations—a man we’ll call “Daniel,” who became convinced he was slowly fading from human perception. At first, it was small things: being skipped in line, ignored in conversation, unseen at a crosswalk. But then it escalated. Friends stopped responding. Familiar faces passed him by like strangers. Eventually, Daniel was left wondering if he was still part of the world at all… or if he had a...
Published: Apr 15, 2026Duration: 31m 26s